Monday, July 11, 2011

Who Decides if Criticism is Constructive?

Raise your hand if you like to be criticized.

Yeah…me neither.

Webster's dictionary defines criticism as "Disapproval expressed by pointing out faults or shortcomings". But, I doubt you need a dictionary to tell you what criticism is any more than you need a dictionary to tell you what pain is. You know it when you feel it.


Perhaps in some (and by "some", I mean very few) cases criticism is warranted, but even then, the likelihood of it bringing about the effect the criticizer was hoping for is going to be on the low side (and by "low", I mean almost non-existent). Why is that? Because people don't like pain and criticism is painful; therefore, as a way of shielding ourselves from the pain, we disregard the validity of the negative things being said about us. This isn't an intentional, conscious, decision. It is the ego protecting itself, and we all do it.  This is what makes the concept of "constructive criticism" so highly unlikely.


We all need to rid ourselves of the notion that we can give someone constructive criticism. We cannot. If constructive criticism exists at all, it exists only at the discretion of the receiver - never the giver - because criticism can never be truly constructive until it is received and acted upon. It is only the receiver that has the power to transform the message, no matter how true or well-intentioned, into something useful or constructive. If the person being criticized doesn’t choose to positively interpret and apply what you have said, then the criticism isn’t constructive at all, regardless of your intent.


Let me offer an example that may help to illustrate the point. I used to have a dog that was incredibly good at leaping into the air and catching anything I threw at him; balls, Frisbees, sticks…he could catch them all. He would launch himself gracefully into the air, arc his body, adjust for the flying object's trajectory, and land gracefully back on all fours with the thrown object proudly gripped in his mouth. Success! Big fun! What a game! However, when I launched the stick at my husband's head his response was less agreeable. As it turns out, he was not as enthused about the “catch-the-stick-in-your-mouth” game as my dog was. One was primed to receive, the other was not. And so it is with criticism.


If there is any other way to make a point about something (and there usually is) avoid using criticism as the delivery method. Unless your receiver is already willing and prepared to deal with the sharp-pointed sticks you’re throwing at his head, he’s unlikely to see the value of the exchange. 


There are alternative approaches with a much better track record, and they are worth learning. Some of the most effective, in my experience, are presented in Marshall Rosenberg's books, Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life, and Speak Peace in a World of Conflict: What You Say Next Will Change Your World . Whether you use these books or other resources, the point is to identify and adopt approaches that have the greatest chance of success, and to discard those which are likely to lead to hard feelings and resistance. 


On the very rare occasion when we must point out another's faults or shortcomings, we would be well advised to follow the advice of newspaper columnist Frank "Parson" Clark, who wrote: "Criticism, like rain, should be gentle enough to nourish a man's growth without destroying his roots."


I still, on occasion, act more like a hurricane than a gentle rain, but I’m learning. How about you?




Thursday, July 7, 2011

When Quitting Makes Sense


Not too long ago I joined a support group for people dealing with chronic health issues. My membership lasted about two weeks and I quit. I couldn’t take the seemingly endless litany of complaints, narcissism and defeatist attitudes that dominated the conversations. I tried to offer an alternate view, one of taking control of our disease and focusing on what we have rather than what we don’t have, but I was, for the most part, ignored. It turns out that misery not only loves company - it demands it. So, the support group folks will have to go on worrying, complaining and picking their scabs without me. I have bowed out, and I make no apologies. Sometimes quitting is the right thing to do.

Tenacity is a virtue that often walks hand-in-hand with success, but when we cling to things that are harmful, tenacity ceases to be a virtue and becomes a vice; a parasite that drains us of health and peace of mind. No one doubts the wisdom of quitting abusive relationships, smoking or other obviously self-destructive behaviors. But not all quitting behaviors are quite that straightforward. Sometimes, vices masquerade as virtues. Sometimes our tenacity causes us to cling to sharks we have mistaken for life rafts. 

I have found that if something hurts, emotionally or physically, it's probably a good idea to stop doing it. I'm not talking about the soreness that comes from moderate exercise or the emotional ambivalence we feel when confronting difficult truths about ourselves. Those are normal and expected components of growth and development. The kind of pain that I'm talking about is the searing pain that develops in your knees every time you go out for a run or the debilitating emotional distress that comes from arguing with and lecturing someone who is obviously not going to change. If it hurts, I mean really hurts, don’t do it. Find a new exercise, a new approach or a new friend. Give yourself permission to quit. Quitting is a source of embarrassment only when it is rooted in laziness.

The older I get, the more I realize that time is short and my efforts must be spent on those activities that provide the greatest chance of being successful and making a positive impact in my life and the lives of others. If it is of little benefit, I have given myself permission to discard it. No harm, no foul. 

As you have heard me say before, your life is the sum total of your experiences. If you fill your life with negative experiences, it logically follows that your life will be less than pleasing to you. So, what are you doing that you need to stop doing? What are you currently hanging on to that you need to cut loose? Why are you afraid to let go? Knowing the answers to these questions is the first step in empowering yourself to get on with your best life. 

I am disappointed that my foray into the support group arena didn’t pan out. I had high hopes for it. We all need the occasional dose of encouragement, some good advice and a coping strategy or two. I am lucky that I still have wonderful people out there who take the time to offer those things to me, and I hope that this blog offers that to you. If it does, I'd really love to hear from you. Feel free to post a comment to this blog or send me an email at dmccall139@gmail.com.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

The Eye of the Beholder

This weekend was the Twilight Zone Marathon; two days of non-stop episodes from the original series. I was mesmerized for hours. I love The Twilight Zone. It is social commentary at its best. Who needs PBS documentaries and social psychologists when you have Rod Serling to remind you of how fragile individuals and societies are? Each episode brings to light the ramifications of our own fears, greed, and prejudices. Each one is a thirty minute crash course in social psychology.


To me, one of the most poignant episodes is the one entitled “The Eye of the Beholder”.  The episode opens with a woman lying in a bed, her face completely bandaged. She is distraught, having undergone repeated medical treatments in an attempt to make her face “acceptable” to society. She desperately pleads with the nurse, begging her for details of when they will remove the bandages and will be able to determine if the treatments have been a success. She tells the sympathetic nurse that, all her life, all she has wanted was for people not to turn away in horror when they saw her. Who can’t relate, on some level, to that type of pain? The twist, of course, is when the bandages are removed to reveal a stunningly beautiful young woman. As the camera pans out, we see that all of those around her are hideously ugly; deformed and pig-like. She, in her youthful beauty, is the aberration. 

While this episode says a lot about the cultural pressures to be physically attractive, its real social import comes in the words of the snout-faced leader seen delivering a political speech at the end of the episode:

“We know now that there must be a single purpose! A single norm! A single approach! A single entity of peoples! A single virtue! A single morality! A single frame of reference! A single philosophy of government! We must cut out all that is different like a cancerous growth! It is essential in this society that we not only have a norm, but that we conform to that norm! Differences weaken us! Variations destroy us! An incredible permissiveness to deviation from this norm is what has ended nations and brought them to their knees! Conformity we must worship and hold sacred! Conformity is the key to survival!”

Do you agree with him? Don’t be so quick to say no…

Too many of us have fallen victim to the insidious message of the snout-faced leader, and we aren’t even aware of it. While there are many of us who would quickly denounce the idea that we would discriminate against someone because of their looks, race or physical handicap, we look at ourselves in a mirror and feel ashamed of what we see there: we are prejudiced against our own faces, our own skin, our own body shape. We are hypocrites, each of us. Differences are fine as long as we’re not the ones being “different”. 

In many ways I wish I could get back my younger years. Not because I want fewer wrinkles, better muscle tone and a trim figure, but because I feel like I was too unforgiving to the girl that I was. I wish I could give her a chance to live free of the unrealistic pressure I put her under. I wish I could go back and have a second chance to focus on the things that really matter; to live free of the pursuit of someone else’s idea of perfection. But I can’t go back, and neither can you. Time flows in one direction. The attitudes we hold today, toward ourselves and others, are the only ones we can change. If we are serious about personal growth and excellence, we have to begin rooting out our prejudices, and we have to start with the ones we hold against ourselves.  

If you want to see your true beauty, you are going to need to look into the eyes of someone you have made feel accepted and loved, just the way they are. A mirror will only be helpful if the grateful eyes you happen to gaze into are your own. Beauty is, after all, in the eye of the beholder.